Hint 1: You will have to have gained access and logged into The Cave website first before you are able to complete with deduction step.

Hint 2: To get the full picture, you’ll need the victim’s crime scene reports and the information from Eloise’s emails, the Moral Vigilante’s Posts, and from the newspaper articles.

Hint 3: It looks like The Cave provided an important disclaimer on their menu.

Hint 4: Maybe by understanding what singular substance could have caused the symptoms seen on the victims, we can narrow down the possible murder weapons.

Need help with the final answer? Click here!